Easy Homemade Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer

It’s time to ditch all of the artificial flavors and corn syrups in store bought coffee creamers. You will love this easy homemade brown sugar coffee creamer! This coffee creamer tastes even better than store bought coffee creamer and it doesn’t have all the added preservatives. If you’re anything like me and don’t like drinking bean water than you’ll love waking up, pouring yourself a cup of hot coffee and adding in the perfect amount of this brown sugar coffee creamer to your cup. I usually have two cups of coffee a day and this creamer is my new favorite! It’s perfect for those chilly mornings when you don’t feel like getting out of bed. Sweet, creamy, and delicious.

Jump to Recipe

Easy Homemade Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer

This coffee creamer recipe is super easy to make, and you probably already have all the ingredients in your pantry. Along with being really easy to make this brown sugar coffee creamer is super delicious. This creamer is so much better for you than store bought creamer. For those of you that don’t know most store-bought coffee creamers contain vegetable oil to help keep the creamer fresh for longer. Along with vegetable oil store bought coffee creams also have a bunch of added artificial flavors and corn syrups. This coffee creamer is perfect for you if you’re looking to cut out all those added preservatives.

This coffee creamer can be used for basic drip coffee, or you can use it to flavor your lattes. You can store your brown sugar coffee creamer for up to two weeks. Although mine has never lasted that long!

If you know me, you know how much I love my coffee. Especially in the mornings. With my late nights blogging and my day to day life being a mom I feel like I need a cup of coffee by my side at all times. LOL. I go through so much coffee creamer every week. It’s pretty crazy. Now I can drink my coffee black, but I really prefer not to. Bean water just isn’t my thing. I like my coffee smooth, sweet, and creamy. Now don’t get me wrong I’m not going to drink a cup of creamer with a little coffee, but I will most definitely be adding some creamer to each cup if I can. I love a good strong cup of coffee with 2-3 tablespoons of creamer.

This warmer weather is getting me so excited for iced lattes and cold brews, but you bet that I’ll still be drinking at least one cup of warm coffee a day. It’s just something about a warm cup of coffee when I wake up in the morning that I love. That’s something I don’t think I’ll ever change about my mornings.

What Does Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer Taste Like?

Unlike homemade coffee creamer that’s made with sweetened condensed milk this coffee creamer is made with a brown sugar simple syrup. The consistency is thin just as the basic store-bought coffee creamer is.

This coffee creamer adds the perfect amount of sweetness to your coffee without it being to be overpowering. It adds a touch of molasses flavor along with a taste similar to sweet caramel toffee. While being super velvety and smooth this coffee creamer takes your coffee experience to a whole new level!

I truly didn’t think I’d ever be able to like homemade coffee creamer more than store bought kind. Lucky for me I won’t have to buy store bought coffee creamer anymore. I hope this coffee creamer recipe inspires you to do the same thing!

Ingredients For Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer

• Brown Sugar
• Water
• Salt
• Vanilla Extract
• Half and Half
• Milk

Step by Step Instructions

1. In a small saucepan over medium heat bring water and brown sugar to boil until the brown sugar is dissolved.
2. Remove from heat. Add in salt and vanilla extract and let cool for 15 minutes.
3. Stir in milk and half and half
4. Pour into a jar and cover with a lid and store in the refrigerator until ready to use. Store for up to two weeks.

And just like that you have a cozy and delicious homemade brown sugar coffee creamer. Double or triple this recipe so that you’ll never run out!

Why You’ll Love This Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer

• Homemade Freshness: Homemade is literally the way to go when it comes to anything. You can’t beat the creamy rich flavor this coffee creamer gives. You’ll no longer have to buy store bought coffee creamers and can ditch all the added preservatives. This homemade coffee creamer will bring your morning cup of coffee to a whole new level!
• Staple Ingredients & Budget Friendly: This recipe requires ingredients that you more than likely have in your pantry. Making this coffee creamer really affordable!
• No Preservatives: Unlike store bought coffee creamer this homemade coffee creamer is made with real and fresh ingredients making it a much healthier option than store bought coffee creamers.
• Control Over Ingredients: Making homemade coffee creamer allows you to have control over all the ingredients. Simply add in another 1/4 cup of brown sugar if you’re looking for a sweeter coffee creamer. If you like things less sweet use 3/4 cup brown sugar instead of 1 cup.

I hope you’re just as excited as I was to start making homemade coffee creamer! I’m so excited to test out new flavors and share them as well. Let me know how you like this brown sugar coffee creamer and don’t forget to come back and leave a comment!

Questions for you!

1. Are you a bean water drinker or do you prefer cream in your coffee?
2. What’s your favorite flavor coffee creamer?
3. What other coffee creamer recipes would you like to see on my blog?